Supreme Court to hear major challenge to partisan gerrymandering

Share
Supreme Court to hear major challenge to partisan gerrymandering

But the Supreme Court has always been tolerant of partisan gerrymandering - and some justices have thought that the court shouldn't even be involved.

Wisconsin has been dealing with the problem of their district lines for several years. The state has appealed a lower court ruling, which found that state Republican lawmakers had violated the constitution when they drew up legislative districts to disadvantage the Democrats. Republicans argue that the results of the districts are hard to keep equal since Democrats tend to congregate together in the big cities.

A Supreme Court ruling faulting the Wisconsin redistricting plan could have far-reaching consequences for the redrawing of electoral districts due after the 2020 USA census. The citizens who are challenging redistricting in Wisconsin specifically designed this case to win over "swing" conservative Justice Anthony Kennedy, who said he would be open to re-examining excessive partisan gerrymandering if a reasonable standard to measure it could be established.

Gerrymandering, a old political art form "as old as the United States itself", King says, is the idea of drawing district lines by structuring them geographically so that they benefit one party or another.

A nonpartisan redistricting process is not only fair and impartial, it also would cost taxpayers far less than than the two million tax dollars and counting used to draw and defend the current maps.

On Monday, the Supreme Court announced that it will hear a case that challenges partisan gerrymandering, and whether the districting that generally aids Republican candidates is unconstitutional. The "narrowest" GOP victor was in the Thirteenth District, with first-time Republican Ted Budd receiving 56 percent-one point above what most political scientists would consider a "competitive" range of 45 to 55 percent.

After winning control of the state legislature in 2010, Wisconsin Republicans redrew the statewide electoral map.

Chief Justice John Roberts (second from right) and Justice Neil Gorsuch (center) walk down the steps of the Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., last week. The redrawn map was rejected as unconstitutional, a first in 30 years. In 2014, the party garnered 52 percent of the vote and 63 Assembly seats.

Paul Smith, a lawyer for the Campaign Legal Center, said gerrymandering "is worse now than any time in recent memory". In November 2016 a three-judge federal panel ruled in favor of Whitford, finding that Wisconsin's maps did unfairly favor the state's Republicans.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Brown even pointed to the district of Gov. Roy Cooper - then Senator Cooper - which jutted away from Nash County into parts of Halifax, Edgecombe, and Wilson counties. Cracking, or spreading, Democratic voters across districts in which Republicans have small majorities wastes all of the Democratic votes when the Republican candidate wins. By placing all the Democrats into a few districts, the votes over the 50.1 percent line are deemed "wasted votes" and are in a sense pointless.

Their lawsuit claimed that Republicans spread Democrats thin among some districts so that they could not achieve a majority.

Indeed, one of the defenses made by Wisconsin officials is that their districts are compact.

Gerrymandering is a term nearly as old as American democracy.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Russian Federation face decisive match against Mexico at Confed Cup
Besides Quaresma, Santos will also have Nani , who will be available to play as a striker, should he wish to rest their Captain. We created chances, we put them under pressure, so we could have got a little more out of this tournament", he told reporters.

Heller won't back Senate GOP health care bill
The bill also scales back federal funding for Medicaid - which is more than half the spending for the program at the state level. Sandoval, a Republican who chose to opt into expanding Medicaid , said 210,000 received health coverage because of the decision.

New blow to GOP health bill: Nevada GOP Sen. Heller opposes
Republican Leader Mitch McConnell has a challenge on unifying his party to successfully repeal the Affordable Care Act . Time is of the essence! The House bill and the Senate offering isn't just a step backward, it blows up the road.

Pemberton Township native wins tight Va. primary race
In the Republican primary, Gillespie beat Stewart 44 percent to 42 percent with Frank Wagner earning 14 percent of the vote. Bush aide Gillespie campaigned off the goodwill he established with Republicans after his narrow loss to Democratic Sen.

Cosby accuser to resume testimony in sex assault trial
Johnson said that she had lotion on her hand and Cosby made her touch his penis, she said. "I wasn't able to", Constand said. However, the next time she visited the actor's home she alleges he gave her three pills that he called herbal supplements.

Sen. Dean Heller Is the First Moderate "No" on Trumpcare
Under both congressional measures, states would instead receive a per capita amount or block grant from the federal government. That would focus the aid more on people with lower incomes than the House legislation, which bases its subsidies on age.

DNC Chairman Tom Perez suggests Democrats could 'take 50 seats' in House
For GOP consultants, tie-every-Democrat-to-Pelosi is a tried-and-true strategy that's been working for more than six years. And we better focus", Ryan said. "It'd be interesting to see if, what'd they say if I was from some other place".

Democratic lawmaker criticizes party brand, Pelosi
But Pelosi continues to command great loyalty from many in the House, and she insisted her position was not in jeopardy. There are, though, reasons to believe Pelosi poses a unique political problem for Democrats.

What's Next on Health Care Draft in Congress
McCain said he's closely reviewing the draft legislation released Thursday and will be speaking with Republican Arizona Gov. "This bill will have devastating consequences for hard working families, the elderly and the sick", Ryan said .

Tubelight Box Office Collection | Salman's Tubelight 1st Day WorldWide Income Reports
Remo also choreographed Salman for the " Radio " song in Kabir Khan's directorial venture " Tubelight ", which released on Friday. But, this Salman Khan film on day 1 may not achieve what is expected from it and what other "Wanted" star films have done so far.

© 2015 Stump Report. All Rights reserved.